I actually like the final result better, but that might be because it has more contrast against the background and goes well with the hair's color scheme. Tattoo is a great touch.
Although I do think that 2nd one has a potential to be great too, just need a little extra contrast touch and it'll do great.
Thank you for sharing your lovely process. It's cool to see how people can integrate both PS and Verve in their work flow.
In fact, I should give that a try!